Print

PhD Dissertation Research Seminar Discussion Scoring Guide

Due Date: End of Unit 10.
Percentage of Course Grade: (varies).

 
  Non-performance Basic Proficient Distinguished
Apply relevant concepts, theories, or materials to demonstrate the qualities and skills of a scholar practitioner. Does not apply concepts, theories, or materials to demonstrate the qualities and skills of a scholar practitioner. Applies concepts, theories, or materials to demonstrate the qualities and skills of a scholar practitioner. Applies relevant concepts, theories, or materials to demonstrate the qualities and skills of a scholar practitioner. Applies relevant concepts, theories, or materials to demonstrate the qualities and skills of a scholar practitioner, including a variety of sources and perspectives.
Support ideas and concepts in initial discussion posts with current, relevant evidence from the literature. Does not support ideas and concepts in the initial discussion post with evidence from the literature. Supports ideas and concepts in the initial discussion post with generic evidence from the literature. Supports ideas and concepts in the initial discussion post with current, relevant evidence from the literature. Supports ideas and concepts in the initial discussion post with current, relevant evidence from a variety of sources and perspectives in the literature.
Respond to peers’ discussion posts using relevant evidence, examples, and questions to advance discussions in a scholarly manner. Does not respond to peers’ discussion posts using evidence, examples, or questions. Responds to peers’ discussion posts using evidence, examples, or questions, but may not advance the discussions in a scholarly manner. Responds to peers’ discussion posts using relevant evidence, examples, and questions to advance discussions in a scholarly manner. Responds to each peer’s discussion post using relevant evidence, examples, and questions to advance discussions in a scholarly manner; discussion responses contribute to other learners’ advancement.